skip to main content skip to footer

Fall Menu 2019


Clams on the Half Shell

$1.50 Each
6 Pieces $9.00 | 12 Pieces $17.00


Delaware Bays (Delaware Bay, NJ) $2.00
Slightly salty; mild, sweet

14.00Chilled Shrimp Cocktail

5 large shrimp, cocktail sauce

12.00Clams Casino

Like no other, created in 1963 by "Chefs" Bill Lutz (of Boathouse fame) and our own Jay C

17.00Local Steamed Clams

Steamed Middleneck clams, lemon & white wine garlic sauce, garlic toast

12.00Meatball Sizzler

Marinara, Parmesan & garlic bread

14.00Mediterranean Calamari

Crispy calamari served with olives, capers & fried hot peppers

10.00Jumbo Bavarian Pretzel

Cheddar horseradish sauce, grain mustard aioli

12.00Burrata & Brussels (GF)

Bacon, apples, maple balsamic vinaigrette

12.00Buffalo Chicken Dip

Served with tortilla chips

Crispy Chicken Wings

(6) $10.00 | (12) $15.00 | (24) $26.00
Your choice of BBQ, sweet chili Thai or classic "Buffalo" style

Tavern Fare

All sandwiches include a choice of French fries or homemade coleslaw.
Substitute sweet potato fries or onion rings for $3

13.00Traditional Cheeseburger

Choice of cheese: cheddar, American, Swiss or provolone; add $1.00 for blue cheese

14.00The Hawkeye Burger

Crispy bacon, crumbled blue cheese, sauteed onions and chipotle mayo

12.00Turkey Burger

Cheddar, avocado, lettuce, tomato, onion & chipotle mayo

15.00Beyond Burger (V)

Plant based burger with cashew mayo and vegan American

16.00Mojo Shrimp Tacos

Shredded cabbage, fire roasted corn & black beans, salsa verde & lime crema

13.00BBQ Spaghetti Squash Nachos

Pulled BBQ squash, cheddar jalapenos, lime crema, tortilla chips

13.00Hot Pastrami Reuben

Swiss, 1000 Island, sauerkraut, marble rye

18.00Short Rib French Dip

Slow braised pulled short ribs, sautéed onions, Swiss cheese & au jus with horseradish sauce

12.00Roast Pork Sandwich

Broccoli rabe, provolone, garlic aioli

15.00Chicken Parmesan Sub

Italian breading, marinara, mozzarella, hoagie roll

14.00Open-Face Meatloaf

White toast, cream spinach, gravy

Tavern Favorites

18.00House Battered Fish & Chips

Fresh cod with beer batter, served with malt vinegar, tartar sauce, French fries and homemade coleslaw

Vegan Chili (V)

Plant based ground "beef", beans, tomatoes and a whole lot of love

Cup $8.00 | Quinoa Bowl $12.00

Chicken Pot Pie

Tender chicken in a creamy sauce with corn, carrots, pearl onions, peas & potatoes topped with a buttery puff pastry
Small $15.00 | Regular $18.00

St Louis Ribs

House dry rubbed and slow smoked. Served with BBQ sauce, French fries and coleslaw
Half Rack $18.00 | Full Rack $25.00


10.00She Crab Soup

8.00New England Clam Chowder

8.00French Onion Soup

7.00Manhattan Clam Chowder (GF)

Soup of the Day



Add to any Salad:
Grilled Shrimp $9.00 | Grilled Chicken $6.00 | Blackened Tuna $10.00

Caesar Salad

Chopped romaine lettuce hearts, croutons & Parmesan cheese with house made Caesar dressing
Small $8.00 | Regular $11.00

Simple Spinach (V) (GF)

Fresh leaf spinach, mushrooms, red onion, vegan parmesan, EVOO and balsamic dressing

Small $8.00 | Regular $12.00

12.00Apple Pecan Salad

Arcadian greens, crumbled blue cheese,candied pecans, dried cranberries, maple balsamic vinaigrette

9.00Classic Wedge Salad (GF)

Iceberg lettuce with blue cheese, bacon & balsamic glaze

House Salad (GF)

Arcadian mixed greens, red onion,  cherry tomatoes, cucumbers, lemon vinaigrette
Small $4.00 | Regular $8.00


Available after 4pm

20.00Linguine & Clams

Local clams and linguine in white wine butter sauce with basil and parmesan cheese

24.00Mongolian Pork Chop

Mashed potatoes, Asian vegetable slaw and Chinese mustard

21.00Grilled Flat Iron Steak

Cheese polenta, garlic spinach, black cherry port wine sauce

29.00Seared Scallops

Butternut squash puree, garlic spinach, apple fennel slaw

Live Maine Lobster (GF)

Steamed or broiled to order, served with drawn butter & lemon, mashed potato and garlic green beans
1 lb. $29.00 | 2 lbs. $59.00 | 4 lbs. $99.00

25.00Black & Blue Tuna

Coconut basmati rice, garlic green beans, seaweed salad with wasabi cream & teriyaki glaze (served rare)  


Mashed potatoes, cream spinach, whiskey glaze

23.00Pecan Crusted Salmon

Mashed potatoes, garlic broccolini, whiskey glaze

17.00Fall Harvest Bowl (V)

Quinoa, roasted butternut squash, parsnips & Brussles sprouts with toasted pecans, dried cranberries and apple cider vinaigrette

Add Chicken $6 | Add Shrimp $9 | Add Tuna $10

20.00Baked Gnocchi Chicken Parmesan

Italian breaded chicken cutlet baked with gnocchi, marinara, mozzarella & ricotta

21.00Short Rib Mac & Cheese

Braised pulled short rib, campanelle pasta, three cheese blend, au jus, Cool Ranch Doritos crust


Our Traditional Tomato Pies

Meatballs | Pepperoni | Sausage | Bacon | Anchovies
Add $1.00 each

Mushrooms | Peppers | Garlic | Onions | Olives | Spinach
Add $0.75 each

12.00Personal Tomato Pie

16.00Large Tomato Pie

19.00"The Works"

4 or more toppings

White Pizza

Ricotta, fresh mozzarella, basil, tomato and garlic
Personal $15.00 | Large $19.00

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Buffalo grilled chicken & blue cheese
Personal $15.00 | Large $19.00

Margherita Pizza

Fresh mozzarella, garlic, basil and tomato sauce
Personal $15.00 | Large $19.00

17.00Gluten Free Vegetable Pizza (GF)

Mediterranean roasted vegetables, mozzarella cheese & balsamic glaze

15.00Gluten Free Cheese Pizza (GF)

Children's Menu

For mates 10 & under.
Soft drink, iced tea or milk included.


5.00Grilled Cheese Sandwich

Served with French fries

10.00Grilled Shrimp or Chicken

Served with linguine

8.00Hamburger Sliders

Add Cheese $0.50 extra
Served with French fries

8.00Chicken Tenders

Served with French fries

6.00Kraft Macaroni & Cheese

8.00Pint Sized Chicken Pot Pie

7.00Flatbread Cheese Pizza

Happy Hour

Everyday 4PM-7PM


12.00Steamed Clams

with lemon & white wine garlic sauce, garlic bread

8.00Firecracker Shrimp

Chicken Wings

BBQ , Buffalo or Sweet Chili Thai

$1.00 each

9.00Philly Cheese Steak

Chicken or Beef

8.00Petite Pot Pie

7.00Bar Pie

Buck a Shuck Oysters & Clams

Delaware Bay Oysters and Local Clams

10.00Chicken Parm Sub

Dessert Menu


7.00Chocolate Lava Cake

Dark chocolate cake overflowing with a molten chocolate pudding center. Served warm with whipped cream

7.00Italian Lemon Cream Cake

Buttery lemon pound cake layered with lemon mascarpone cream


7.00Buckalew’s Brownie Sundae

Ghirardelli  double dark chocolate brownie served  warm with vanilla ice cream, Hershey’s chocolate syrup, whipped cream, chopped peanuts, chocolate sprinkles and a cherry on top


7.00Banana Foster Bread Pudding

Warm brown sugar banana rum custard with crème anglaise





Coffee/Hot Tea




Draft Beers


6.75Downeast Cider

Original Recipe Hard Cider; lightly carbonated, unfiltered & gluten free, ME  5.1 ABV

5.25Yuengling Lager

American Amber/Red Lager, PA 4.4% ABV

5.25Miller Lite

Light Lager, WI 4.2% ABV

7.00Guinness Draught

Irish Dry Stout, Ireland 4.2% ABV


Euro Pale Lager, Ireland 5.0% ABV


Irish Red Ale, Ireland 4.5% ABV

7.00Stella Artois

Euro Pale Lager, Belgium 5.0% ABV

6.00Blue Moon

Witbier, CO - 5.4% ABV

8.00Buckalew's IPA

American IPA; Our very own IPA brewed at Cricket Hill, NJ 6.5% ABV

6.50Bells Oberon

American Wheat Ale; Mixes a spicy hop character with mild fruit aromas, MI 5.8% ABV  


8.00Allagash White

Witbier; Spiced with coriander & Curacao orange peel, ME 5.0% ABV

7.00Kane Head High

American IPA, NJ 6.5% ABV

7.00Cape May IPA

American IPA named for America’s Oldest Seaside Resort, Cape May IPA is loaded with floral and citrus notes, slightly bitter with a zesty finish, NJ 6.3% ABV  

8.00Dogfish 90 Minute

Imperial IPA; continuous hopping sets this IPA apart  from the rest, DE 9.0% ABV  

7.00Kane Sneakbox

Pale Ale; Brewed with citra hops for a fruity, citrusy bouquet, NJ 5.4% ABV 

4.50Narragansett Lager

Lager, Six row malt & Pacific Northwest hops, RI 5.0% ABV

6.50Narragansett Del’s Shandy

Lemonade lager; balance of malt sweet & citrus tart, RI  4.7% ABV  

8.00Brotherton IPA

IPA; unfiltered, insanely juicy & intense hop flavor, NJ 6.6% ABV

7.00Forgotten Boardwalk Ghost Cat

Wheat Pale Ale; Brewed in conjunction with NJ Maritime Museum and Buckalew’s, NJ 4.5% ABV

8.00Brotherton Jersey Devil

Double IPA; obsessively aromatic Northeastern style with peachy tangerine juice, pine resin and dank earthy-green hops, NJ  8.4% ABV  

Wine List

Red Wine By The Glass

14.00J Vineyards Pinot Noir


11.00Gascon Malbec


14.00Louis Martini Cabernet


12.00Greg Norman Shiraz


13.00Charles Smith Boom Boom Syrah


White Wine By The Glass

9.00Ecco Domani Pinot Grigio


11.00Starborough Sauvignon Blanc


10.00William Hill Central Coast Chardonnay


10.00La Marca Prosecco

187 ml

10.00Kung Fu Girl Riesling


7.50Barefoot Rose


House Wines By The Glass


7.50Sauvignon Blanc

7.50Pinot Grigio

7.50White Zinfandel

7.50Pinot Noir


7.50Cabernet Sauvignon


Pinot Grigio

28.00Maso Canalli, Trentino


27.00J Pinot Gris, California


23.00Ecco Domani, Italy


20.00Canyon Road, California


Sauvignon Blanc

25.00Starborough, New Zealand


22.00Kim Crawford, New Zealand


20.00Canyon Road, California



23.00Kung Fu Girl, Washington



30.00Whispering Angel, Provence, France


20.00White Zinfandel, Canyon Road, California



58.00Jordan, Russian River


21.00William Hill Central Coast


20.00Canyon Road, California


Champagne & Sparkling Wine

225.00Moet & Chandon Dom Perignon, Epernay


80.00Pierrer-Jouet Grand Brut, Eden


50.00J Vineyards Rose


28.00La Marca Prosecco, Italy


Half Bottle Sparkling

12.00Chandon Brut Champagne 187ML


10.00La Marco Prosecco, Italy


Half Bottle White Wine

Pinot Noir

75.00Talisman Winery "Adastra Vineyard", Napa


38.00Chateau St. Jean, Sonoma


30.00J Vineyards, California


20.00Proverb, California



23.00DaVinci, DOCG, Tuscany


49.00Marchese Antinori Classico Riserva



28.00Greg Norman Shiraz, Limestone Coast


26.00Charles Smith Boom Boom Syrah, Washington



75.00 Twomey Merlot, Napa


20.00Canyon Road, California


Alternative Reds & Blends

58.00Spring Valley Frederick Red Blend, Washington


26.00Gascon Malbec, Argentina


Cabernet Sauvignon

295.00Opus One, Napa


250.00Opus One, Napa


220.00Opus One, Napa


165.00Silver Oak, Napa


150.00Silver Oak, Napa


90.00Jordan, Alexander Valley


70.00Stags' Leap Artemis, Napa


32.00Louis Martini Sonoma Cabernet


26.00Charles Smith, Washington


20.00Canyon Road, California


Half Bottle Red Wine

Port by the Glass

8.00Grahams Tawny Port

8.00Grahams Ruby Port

Sushi Menu

Sushi now open Friday - Wednesday, closed Thursday.

Specialty Platters

(served with Miso soup & Sushi side salad)

20.00Vegetarian Platter

1 vegetarian, 1 avocado & 1 sweet potato roll

25.00California Platter

3 California Rolls

28.00Spicy Combo Platter

1 spicy tuna, 1 spicy shrimp & 1 spicy salmon roll

26.00Tuna or Salmon Lover Platter

1 spicy tuna or salmon roll, 1 tuna or salmon roll & 3 tuna or salmon nigiri or sashimi

35.00Yellowtail Special Platter

1 neghihamachi roll, 1 spicy yellowtail roll & 3 pieces of yellowtail nigiri

28.00Shrimp Special Platter

1 spicy shrimp, 1 shrimp tempura roll & 3 pieces of Ebi

45.00LBI Combo Platter

4 pieces each of crunchy tuna, spicy salmon & rainbow 4 each of nigiri & sashimi, your choice

75.00Love Boat for 2

1 spicy yellowtail roll, 1 spicy tuna roll, 1 spicy salmon roll, 1 shrimp tempura roll, 10 pieces of nigiri or sashimi

Nigiri / Sashimi

(per piece)








3.00Flying Fish Roe

3.00White Tuna


Salmon roe


Extras / Substitutions

2.00Rice Paper


0.50Cream Cheese

2.00Soy Paper

1.00Extra Sauce


5.50Gekkikan Sake


24.00Ty Ku Jun Mai Black


18.00Ty Ku Jun Mai Silver


Featured Appetizers

7.00Fried Vegetable Spring Roll

7.00Steamed Shrimp Shumai

7.00Fried Squid on a Skewer

7.00Mixed Vegetable Tempura

8.00Steamed Wasabi Pork Shumai

Rice Bowls

14.00Vegetarian Bowl

Rice, carrot, cucumber, avocado with spicy, sweet mayonnaise, wasabi sauce

25.00Multi-Color Bowl

Rice & assorted fish

18.00Spicy Poke Bowl

Your choice of marinated tuna or salmon with sushi rice, mixed greens, cucumber, carrot, avocado, seaweed salad & fried onions


1.50Green Tea

3.00Side Salad

2.50Miso Soup


Fried or steamed

5.50Seaweed Salad

9.00Kani Salad

2.00Sushi Rice

7.00Calamari Salad


Rolls / Hand Rolls

8.00California Roll

Crabstick, cucumber, avocado

9.00Philadelphia Roll

Smoked salmon, cream cheese & cucumber

9.00Alaska Roll

Salmon, avocado, cucumber

9.00Spicy Roll

Choice of tuna, salmon, yellowtail or shrimp, all with cucumber

9.00Seaweed Salad Roll

Seaweed salad, cucumber & avocado

11.00Tempura California Roll

Deep fried with spicy sauce



6.00Avocado Roll

7.00Salmon Roll

10.00Eel Roll

Cucumber or avocado



6.00Crabstick Roll

7.00Sweet Potato Roll

7.00Cucumber & Avocado

9.00Tuna & Avocado

9.00Salmon & Avocado

7.00Vegetarian Roll

Special Rolls

14.00Neghihamachi Roll

Yellow tail, cucumber & green onion with wasabi sauce

10.00Shrimp Tempura Roll

Shrimp tempura, avocado & cucumber with sweet & spicy sauce

14.00Tennessee Roll

Tuna, cucumber & avocado on topped with masago & spicy sauce

15.00Creamy Crab Roll

Crabstick tempura, cream cheese, avocado, cucumber, crispy rice & green onion with wasabi sauce

15.00Crunchy Roll

Choice of tuna, salmon, or shrimp
Served with cucumber & avocado & topped with tobiko, crispy rice & spicy sauce

18.00Jumbo Crab Roll

Jumbo crab meat, cucumber, avocado & masago with spicy sauce

17.00Summer Roll

Spicy shrimp, crab stick, cucumber, avocado, carrot & lettuce with sweet chili sauce rolled in rice paper

15.00Hawaiian Roll

Spicy tuna & cucumber roll with avocado, tobikko & wasabi sauce

16.00Spider Roll

Soft shell crab tempura, avocado & cucumber topped with tobikko spicy/ sweet sauce

16.00Dragon Roll

Eel & cucumber roll topped with avocado & unagi sauce

18.00Rainbow Roll

California roll topped with assorted fish

17.00Sushi Lobster Roll

Lobster salad, cucumber & avocado

18.00Samurai Roll

Tuna, salmon, cream cheese, mango sriracha sauce, avocado & crab stick  wrapped in thinly sliced cucumber with jalapeño sauce           **no rice or seaweed**


18.00Bangkok Roll

Cucumber & spicy tuna roll topped with spicy scallop & green onion, finished off with blow torch with sriracha sauce

18.00Easter Roll

Tuna & avocado roll topped with salm

18.00Dynamite Roll

Tuna & cucumber roll topped with tuna, crispy rice & spicy sauce

18.00Shrimp Lover Roll

Shrimp tempura roll topped with shrimp and avocado with spicy/sweet sauce

18.00White Dragon Roll

White tuna & cucumber roll topped with white tuna & spicy wasabi sauce

18.00Beach Haven Roll

Shrimp tempura roll topped with eel, sweet & spicy sauce

16.00Volcano Roll

Choice of tuna, salmon, or yellowtail Cucumber topped with tobiko, masago, ikura, crispy rice & spicy wasabi sauce

18.00Chattanooga Roll

Shrimp tempura, cream cheese roll topped with spicy tuna, crispy rice, served with honey & spicy sauce

18.00Kamikaze Roll

Spicy tuna & cucumber roll with white tuna, grilled jalapeño on top, served with spicy sauce, wasabi & sriracha sauce

18.00Valentine Roll

White tuna, tuna, avocado & strawberry wrapped in soy paper with wasabi & spicy sauce

Buckalew’s Specialties

18.00Old Barney Roll

Tempura shrimp topped with tuna & white tuna with spicy & eel sauces

17.00Jay’s Special Roll

Spicy Tuna, lettuce & avocado topped with crab meat & fried onion with creamy jalapeño & sweet sauce

18.00Buckalew’s Roll

Chopped White Tuna, with tobiko, special sauce, mango sriracha sauce, spicy salmon, cucumber sprinkled with green onion, finished with a blow torch

18.00Paige Ann Roll

Cucumber, avocado & soft shell crab tempura topped with spicy scallop, finished with blow torch, Kimchee & wasabi sauce

18.00South Bay Roll

Soft-shell Crab tempura and cucumber topped with jumbo lump crab and seaweed salad with Kimchee sauce

18.00Queen City Roll

Soft shell crab & avocado topped with spicy tuna, wasabi & eel sauces

18.00Holyoke Roll

Tuna & avocado topped with spicy scallop and Kimchee sauce

18.00Wooden Jetty Roll

Tempura shrimp topped with jumbo lump crab and mango sriracha sauce

18.00Mackenzie Special Roll

Tempura shrimp & avocado topped with tuna, seaweed salad & Kimchee sauce

18.00Barnegat Roll

Spicy tuna & cream cheese tempura topped with rice crispy & spicy/sweet sauce

18.00Popcorn Lobster Roll

Spicy salmon and Kimchee sauce topped with lobster tempura, avocado, tobikko & cilantro


Catering Menu

Hors D'oeurves

Prices from $9 to $12 according to variety & number of choices

Buffalo Shrimp

Clams Casino

Petite Crab Cakes

Spinach & Feta Mushrooms

Shrimp Cocktail

Bruschetta Crostini

Vegetable Spring Rolls

Chicken Dumplings

Mozzarella Sticks

Chicken Wings


Prices range from $24 to $31 per person according to variety
Includes choice of Garden or Caesar Salad, rolls & butter
Includes non-alcoholic beverages, coffee and tea

Choose Three

Chicken Parmesan

Crispy Italian Breading, Marinara, Mozzarella, Parmesan, Penne Pasta

Chicken Francaise

White Wine, Lemon, Butter, Penne Pasta

Flat Iron Steak

Mashed Potatoes, Chef's Vegetable, Blackberry Port Wine Sauce

Penne Vodka

Garlic, Shallots, Tomato, Vodka Cream, Parmesan

Mediterranean Shrimp

Seared Garlic Shrimp, Artichokes, Kalamata Olives, Capers, Pesto Cream, Penne Pasta

Sesame Crusted Salmon

Coconut Rice, Chef's Vegetable, Teriyaki, Wasabi Cream

Jumbo Lump Crab Cake

Mashed Potatoes, Chef's Vegetable, Rosemarie Sauce

Stuffed Flounder

Jumbo Lump Crab, Mashed Potatoes, Chef's Vegetable, White Wine Lemon Sauce

Seasonal Vegetarian/Vegan

Please Inquire

Seasonal Pork Chop

Please Inquire


Mashed Potatoes, Chef's Vegetable, Bearnaise Sauce

Chili Lime Vegetable Stir Fry

Squash, Zucchini, Black Beans, Corn, Coconut Rice, Queso Fresco, Lime Crema

Dinner Buffet

Prices range from $24 to $31 per person according to variety
Includes choice of Garden or Caesar Salad, rolls & butter
Includes non-alcoholic beverages, coffee and tea

Add a Premium Dessert to Any Package
Choice of One - $4/person
Chocolate Lava Cake | Fruit Platter with Chocolate Sauce | Meyer's Lemon Cake

Choice of One Starch & One Vegetable
Roasted Potatoes | Coconut Rice | Balsamic Roasted Vegetables | Garlic Broccoli and Cauliflower

Choice of Three

Chicken Francaise

White Wine, Lemon & Butter

Flank Steak Au Poivre

Green Peppercorn Brandy Cream

Penne Vodka

Garlic, Shallots, Parmesan in Tomato & Vodka Cream Sauce

Mediterranean Shrimp

Seared Garlic Shrimp, Artichokes, Kalamata Olives, Capers, Pesto Cream, Penne Pasta

Stuffed Flounder

Jumbo Lump Crab, White Wine Lemon Sauce

Chicken Parmesan

Crispy Italian Breading, Marinara, Mozzarella, Parmesan

Prime Rib

Slow Roasted, Au Jus

Penne Alfredo

Add Crabmeat, $4/person

Sausage and Pepper

Marinara, Basil Sherry, Hint of Cream


Steamed, White or Red Sauce

Lunch Buffet - $19

Includes choice of Garden or Caesar Salad, rolls & butter
Includes non-alcoholic beverages, coffee and tea

Includes Assorted House Baked Cookies

Choice of Three

Chicken Salad – Sandwich or Wrap

Crab Cake Slider

Tuna Salad – Sandwich or Wrap

Ham and Cheese – Sandwich or Wrap

Turkey and Cheese – Sandwich or Wrap

Roast Beef Sandwich

Chicken Caesar Wrap

Pulled Pork Slider

BBQ or Buffalo Chicken Slider

Roasted Vegetables Wrap

Sweet Chili Sesame Chicken Tenders

Cheesesteak Sliders

Cheeseburger Sliders

Cheese and Crudité Display

Antipasto Display