skip to main content skip to footer

Fall Menu 2019

Appetizers

Clams on the Half Shell

$1.50 Each
6 Pieces $9.00 | 12 Pieces $17.00

Oysters:

Delaware Bays (Delaware Bay, NJ) $2.00
Slightly salty; mild, sweet

Chilled Shrimp Cocktail14.00

5 large shrimp, cocktail sauce

Clams Casino12.00

Like no other, created in 1963 by "Chefs" Bill Lutz (of Boathouse fame) and our own Jay C

Local Steamed Clams17.00

Steamed Middleneck clams, lemon & white wine garlic sauce, garlic toast

Meatball Sizzler12.00

Marinara, Parmesan & garlic bread

Mediterranean Calamari14.00

Crispy calamari served with olives, capers & fried hot peppers

Jumbo Bavarian Pretzel10.00

Cheddar horseradish sauce, grain mustard aioli

Burrata & Brussels (GF)12.00

Bacon, apples, maple balsamic vinaigrette

Buffalo Chicken Dip12.00

Served with tortilla chips

Crispy Chicken Wings

(6) $10.00 | (12) $15.00 | (24) $26.00
Your choice of BBQ, sweet chili Thai or classic "Buffalo" style

Tavern Fare

All sandwiches include a choice of French fries or homemade coleslaw.
Substitute sweet potato fries or onion rings for $3

Traditional Cheeseburger13.00

Choice of cheese: cheddar, American, Swiss or provolone; add $1.00 for blue cheese

The Hawkeye Burger14.00

Crispy bacon, crumbled blue cheese, sauteed onions and chipotle mayo

Turkey Burger12.00

Cheddar, avocado, lettuce, tomato, onion & chipotle mayo

Beyond Burger (V)15.00

Plant based burger with vegan ranch and vegan American

Mojo Shrimp Tacos16.00

Shredded cabbage, fire roasted corn & black beans, salsa verde & lime crema

Hot Pastrami Reuben13.00

Swiss, 1000 Island, sauerkraut, marble rye

Short Rib French Dip18.00

Slow braised pulled short ribs, sautéed onions, Swiss cheese & au jus with horseradish sauce

Roast Pork Sandwich12.00

Broccoli rabe, provolone, garlic aioli

Chicken Parmesan Sub15.00

Italian breading, marinara, mozzarella, hoagie roll

Open-Face Meatloaf14.00

White toast, cream spinach, gravy

Hot Open Face Turkey 12.00

Natural roast turkey and gravy on white toast

Soup & Half Sandwich10.00

Choose from:

Pastrami Reuben, Roasted Pork, Chicken Parm or Grilled Cheese

Tavern Favorites

House Battered Fish & Chips18.00

Fresh cod with beer batter, served with malt vinegar, tartar sauce, French fries and homemade coleslaw

Turkey Pot Pie

Tender turkey in a creamy sauce with corn, carrots, pearl onions, peas & potatoes topped with a buttery puff pastry
Small $13.00 | Regular $16.00

St Louis Ribs

House dry rubbed and slow smoked. Served with BBQ sauce, French fries and coleslaw
Half Rack $18.00 | Full Rack $25.00

Bratwurst & Knockwurst12.00

French fires, sauerkraut, Dijon cream sauce

Soups

She Crab Soup10.00

French Onion Soup8.00

Manhattan Clam Chowder (GF)7.00

Soup of the Day

MP

Salads

Add to any Salad:
Grilled Shrimp $9.00 | Grilled Chicken $6.00 | Blackened Tuna $10.00

Caesar Salad

Chopped romaine lettuce hearts, croutons & Parmesan cheese with house made Caesar dressing
Small $8.00 | Regular $11.00

Simple Spinach (V) (GF)

Fresh leaf spinach, mushrooms, red onion, vegan parmesan, EVOO and balsamic dressing

Small $8.00 | Regular $12.00

Apple Pecan Salad12.00

Arcadian greens, crumbled blue cheese,candied pecans, dried cranberries, maple balsamic vinaigrette

Classic Wedge Salad (GF)9.00

Iceberg lettuce with blue cheese, bacon & balsamic glaze

House Salad (GF)

Arcadian mixed greens, red onion,  cherry tomatoes, cucumbers, lemon vinaigrette
Small $4.00 | Regular $8.00

Entrees

Available after 4pm


Linguine & Clams20.00

Local clams and linguine in white wine butter sauce with basil and parmesan cheese

Mongolian Pork Chop24.00

Mashed potatoes, braised teryiaki cabbage and Chinese mustard

Grilled Flat Iron Steak21.00

Cheese polenta, garlic spinach, cranberry port wine sauce

Seared Scallops29.00

Butternut squash puree, garlic spinach, apple fennel slaw

Live Maine Lobster (GF)

Steamed or broiled to order, served with drawn butter & lemon, mashed potato and garlic green beans
1 lb. $29.00 | 2 lbs. $59.00 | 4 lbs. $99.00

Black & Blue Tuna23.00

Coconut basmati rice, garlic green beans, seaweed salad with wasabi cream & teriyaki glaze (served rare)  

Meatloaf19.00

Mashed potatoes, cream spinach, whiskey glaze

Pecan Crusted Salmon25.00

Mashed potatoes, broccoli rabe, whiskey glaze

Fall Harvest Bowl (V)17.00

Quinoa, roasted butternut squash, parsnips, chic peas & Brussles sprouts with toasted pecans, dried cranberries and apple cider vinaigrette

Add Chicken $6 | Add Shrimp $9 | Add Tuna $10

Baked Gnocchi Chicken Parmesan20.00

Italian breaded chicken cutlet baked with gnocchi, marinara, mozzarella & ricotta

Short Rib Mac & Cheese23.00

Braised pulled short rib, campanelle pasta, three cheese blend, au jus, Cool Ranch Doritos crust

Turkey Platter15.00

Natural roast turkey with gravy, mashed potatoes, classic stuffing, garlic green beans and cranberry sauce

Pizza

Our Traditional Tomato Pies

Meatballs | Pepperoni | Sausage | Bacon | Anchovies
Add $1.00 each

Mushrooms | Peppers | Garlic | Onions | Olives | Spinach
Add $0.75 each

Personal Tomato Pie12.00

Large Tomato Pie16.00

"The Works"19.00

4 or more toppings

White Pizza

Ricotta, fresh mozzarella, basil, tomato and garlic
Personal $15.00 | Large $19.00

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Buffalo grilled chicken & blue cheese
Personal $15.00 | Large $19.00

Margherita Pizza

Fresh mozzarella, garlic, basil and tomato sauce
Personal $15.00 | Large $19.00

Gluten Free Vegetable Pizza (GF)17.00

Mediterranean roasted vegetables, mozzarella cheese & balsamic glaze

Gluten Free Cheese Pizza (GF)15.00

Children's Menu

For mates 10 & under.
Soft drink, iced tea or milk included.

Menu

Grilled Cheese Sandwich5.00

Served with French fries

Grilled Shrimp or Chicken10.00

Served with linguine

Hamburger Sliders8.00

Add Cheese $0.50 extra
Served with French fries

Chicken Tenders8.00

Served with French fries

Kraft Macaroni & Cheese6.00

Pint Sized Chicken Pot Pie8.00

Flatbread Cheese Pizza7.00

Happy Hour

Everyday 4PM-7PM
BAR ONLY

Menu

Steamed Clams12.00

with lemon & white wine garlic sauce, garlic bread

Firecracker Shrimp8.00

Chicken Wings

BBQ , Buffalo or Sweet Chili Thai

$1.00 each

Philly Cheese Steak9.00

Chicken or Beef

Petite Pot Pie8.00

Bar Pie7.00

Buck a Shuck Oysters & Clams

Delaware Bay Oysters and Local Clams

Chicken Parm Sub10.00

Dessert Menu

Desserts

Chocolate Lava Cake7.00

Dark chocolate cake overflowing with a molten chocolate pudding center. Served warm with whipped cream

Italian Lemon Cream Cake7.00

Buttery lemon pound cake layered with lemon mascarpone cream

 

Buckalew’s Brownie Sundae7.00

Ghirardelli  double dark chocolate brownie served  warm with vanilla ice cream, Hershey’s chocolate syrup, whipped cream, chopped peanuts, chocolate sprinkles and a cherry on top

 

Banana Foster Bread Pudding 7.00

Warm brown sugar banana rum custard with crème anglaise

 

Beverages

Espresso

Cappuccino

Coffee/Hot Tea

Cordials

Ports

Cognacs

Draft Beers

Menu

Downeast Cider6.75

Original Recipe Hard Cider; lightly carbonated, unfiltered & gluten free, ME  5.1 ABV

Yuengling Lager5.25

American Amber/Red Lager, PA 4.4% ABV

Miller Lite5.25

Light Lager, WI 4.2% ABV

Guinness Draught7.00

Irish Dry Stout, Ireland 4.2% ABV

Harp6.75

Euro Pale Lager, Ireland 5.0% ABV

Smithwick's6.75

Irish Red Ale, Ireland 4.5% ABV

Stella Artois7.00

Euro Pale Lager, Belgium 5.0% ABV

Blue Moon6.00

Witbier, CO - 5.4% ABV

Buckalew's IPA8.00

American IPA; Our very own IPA brewed at Cricket Hill, NJ 6.5% ABV

Bells Oberon6.50

American Wheat Ale; Mixes a spicy hop character with mild fruit aromas, MI 5.8% ABV  

 

Allagash White8.00

Witbier; Spiced with coriander & Curacao orange peel, ME 5.0% ABV

Kane Head High7.00

American IPA, NJ 6.5% ABV

Cape May IPA7.00

American IPA named for America’s Oldest Seaside Resort, Cape May IPA is loaded with floral and citrus notes, slightly bitter with a zesty finish, NJ 6.3% ABV  

Dogfish 90 Minute8.00

Imperial IPA; continuous hopping sets this IPA apart  from the rest, DE 9.0% ABV  

Kane Sneakbox7.00

Pale Ale; Brewed with citra hops for a fruity, citrusy bouquet, NJ 5.4% ABV 

Narragansett Lager4.50

Lager, Six row malt & Pacific Northwest hops, RI 5.0% ABV

Narragansett Del’s Shandy 6.50

Lemonade lager; balance of malt sweet & citrus tart, RI  4.7% ABV  

Brotherton IPA8.00

IPA; unfiltered, insanely juicy & intense hop flavor, NJ 6.6% ABV

Forgotten Boardwalk Ghost Cat7.00

Wheat Pale Ale; Brewed in conjunction with NJ Maritime Museum and Buckalew’s, NJ 4.5% ABV

Brotherton Jersey Devil8.00

Double IPA; obsessively aromatic Northeastern style with peachy tangerine juice, pine resin and dank earthy-green hops, NJ  8.4% ABV  

Wine List

Red Wine By The Glass

J Vineyards Pinot Noir14.00

2016

Gascon Malbec11.00

2015

Louis Martini Cabernet14.00

2014

Greg Norman Shiraz12.00

2016

Charles Smith Boom Boom Syrah13.00

2015

White Wine By The Glass

Ecco Domani Pinot Grigio9.00

2017

Starborough Sauvignon Blanc11.00

2017

William Hill Central Coast Chardonnay10.00

2016

La Marca Prosecco10.00

187 ml

Kung Fu Girl Riesling10.00

2016

Barefoot Rose7.50

2018

House Wines By The Glass

Chardonnay7.50

Sauvignon Blanc7.50

Pinot Grigio7.50

White Zinfandel7.50

Pinot Noir7.50

Merlot7.50

Cabernet Sauvignon7.50

Rose7.50

Pinot Grigio

Maso Canalli, Trentino28.00

2017

J Pinot Gris, California27.00

2016

Ecco Domani, Italy23.00

2017

Canyon Road, California20.00

2017

Sauvignon Blanc

Starborough, New Zealand25.00

2017

Kim Crawford, New Zealand22.00

2017

Canyon Road, California20.00

2016

Riesling

Kung Fu Girl, Washington23.00

2017

Blush

Whispering Angel, Provence, France30.00

2017

White Zinfandel, Canyon Road, California20.00

2017

Chardonnay

Jordan, Russian River58.00

2015

William Hill Central Coast21.00

2017

Canyon Road, California20.00

2017

Champagne & Sparkling Wine

Moet & Chandon Dom Perignon, Epernay225.00

2009

Pierrer-Jouet Grand Brut, Eden80.00

NV

J Vineyards Rose50.00

NV

La Marca Prosecco, Italy28.00

NV

Half Bottle Sparkling

Chandon Brut Champagne 187ML12.00

NV

La Marco Prosecco, Italy10.00

NV

Half Bottle White Wine

Pinot Noir

Talisman Winery "Adastra Vineyard", Napa75.00

2011

Chateau St. Jean, Sonoma38.00

2016

J Vineyards, California30.00

2016

Proverb, California20.00

2016

Chianti

DaVinci, DOCG, Tuscany23.00

2016

Marchese Antinori Classico Riserva49.00

2014

Shiraz/Syrah

Greg Norman Shiraz, Limestone Coast28.00

2014

Charles Smith Boom Boom Syrah, Washington26.00

2015

Merlot

Twomey Merlot, Napa75.00

2004/2008

Canyon Road, California20.00

2017

Alternative Reds & Blends

Spring Valley Frederick Red Blend, Washington58.00

2014

Gascon Malbec, Argentina26.00

2016

Cabernet Sauvignon

Opus One, Napa295.00

2014

Opus One, Napa250.00

2012

Opus One, Napa220.00

2008

Silver Oak, Napa165.00

2013

Silver Oak, Napa150.00

2011

Jordan, Alexander Valley90.00

2014

Stags' Leap Artemis, Napa70.00

2015

Louis Martini Sonoma Cabernet32.00

2016

Charles Smith, Washington26.00

2016

Canyon Road, California20.00

2017

Half Bottle Red Wine

Port by the Glass

Grahams Tawny Port8.00

Grahams Ruby Port8.00